The
Best Band You're Not Listening To Introducing
16 Horsepower
Every year, TV Guide dedicates a special issue to a fledgling
television show. Its always called The
Best Show Youre Not Watching, and, ironically, it always
features one of the only shows you are likely to be watching. That
is, the profiled show is one that has experienced a slight drop
in Nielson ratings, but everyone except for television execs, advertising
execs, and TV Guide understands that Nielson ratings are
about as scientific as chad counting. The featured show is usually
a very good show and one that you know plenty about and like to
discuss with your friends over mocha lattes. TV Guide is
not unearthing any PBS gems here; they are helping their network
advertisers promote a product.
Now, the title of this article is The Best Band Youre
Not Listening To. But Im not going to do the TV Guide
thing and sing the praises of some band whose albums you already
own. Im not going to talk about the Dave Matthews Band just
because their new album isnt the best-selling album in America.
Im going to talk about 16 Horsepower, and the chances are
very good that youve never heard of them unless you are a
music aficionado (16 Horsepower is a critically acclaimed underground
band), you live near Denver (where they are from) or you live in
the Netherlands (where they are popular in a rabid, U2 sort of way).
In May, the Denver Post called 16 Horsepower the best rock
band in Colorado. A few months ago, the bands most recent
album, Secret South,landed on Top 10 lists for 2000 by Amazon.com
and CD Now. They enjoy celebrity status in Amsterdam, where their
shows sell out months in advance, where they are mobbed in the streets
and were recently the subject of an hour-long television special.
The problem is that in the U.S., as you well know, creativity doesnt
sell well. Sameness does. Britney Spears and Destinys Child
do. Its the same reason Pearl Harbor and The Mummy
Returns are setting box office records this summer while films
such as With aFriend Like Harry are largely ignored. Theres
no accounting for a nation's taste, except when it is at least partially
driven by the folks who stand to make a dime. Its the way
of the consumer capitalist world, and 16 Horsepower and a thousand
other unique bands that we will never hear of are part of the fallout.
But I digress.
16 Horsepower consists of David Eugene Edwards (vocals, accordion,
guitar, banjo, hurdy-gurdy), Jean-Yves Tola (drums, piano), Stephen
Taylor (lead guitar) and Pascal Humbert (standup bass). Edwards
and Tola met in 1992 in California where they were both doing carpentry
work for B-film producer Roger Corman. The two musicians hit it
off, discovering solidarity as friends and artists. Before long,
they had formed a band, moved to Colorado and recorded a self-titled
EP.
Soon after, 16 Horsepower signed with A&M Records and recorded
their first LP, Sackcloth and Ashes, for which they achieved
widespread critical acclaim. Since that time, theyve produced
two more studio albums, Low Estate (A&M) and Secret
South (Razor and Tie), and one live album, Hoarse, which
was previously released in Europe and has just been distributed
in the U.S. by Checkered Past Records.
Describing 16 Horsepowers music is an exercise in frustration.
Its a full, stirring mixture of minor guitar chords and hollow
percussion playing catch-up with Edwards throaty, assailing
vocals. Reviewers usually employ adjectives like Appalachian,
roots, gothic, and alt-country
to describe 16 HPs sound, and always with modifiers: something
like; a combination of; somewhere in between.
In short, 16 Horsepower is too unique, too difficult to describe,
too unpalatable for them to ever be a successful band. And thats
just fine with them.
Their music requires thought and passion, and I think people
on a pulp level arent interested in that anymore, Rob
Ferbrache, the bands former lap-steel player who now helps
produce the albums, told the Denver Post. Sure, they
want to sell records and have people come to their concerts, but
they can hold their heads up proud because they are doing what they
want to do.
In May, I attended a 16 Horsepower show in Boulder, Colorado. The
Fox Theater was sold out, and before the concert the room was filled
with a hazy, half-drunken, pre-concert buzz. The bands entrance
on stage was the most uneventful I had ever seen. Edwards walked
out, sat on a stool, picked up his guitar, and started playing.
His band-mates stood far apart from him and played their own instruments,
hardly noticing he was there. There was no back-to-back David Lee
Roth/Eddie Van Halen smiling showmanship, no face-to-face Jon Bon
Jovi/Richie Sambora guitar dueling (excuse the glam rock references).
Tola, Taylor and the Humbert might as well have been playing on
three separate stages. And Edwards might as well have been playing
in his bedroom. He sat on his stool the whole time, hardly talking
at all between songs (save for the occasional deadpan Thank
you for clapping). He strummed his guitar, squeezed his box
accordion, and sang deeply into his mike, nearly swallowing it at
times.
Sound boring? It wasnt. It was entrancing. The crowd didnt
budge. They listened. Intensely.
Though Edwards remained still, he effused with presence. He seemed
to hover above the stage. His eyes bulged and glowered at the audience.
Suddenly, 16 HP song lyrics, which are easily ignored on albums,
became the central presence of their music. It became clear that
Edwards had something to say:
Youre thinking when this is all over
Well all sit back and laugh.
I dont think so, see,
Cause I done the math.
Aint looking to gain honor, no
Not among the thieves;
Ill be right beside you, friend,
In judgment on my knees. (from Clogger)
Let us not mince our words;
Let us say it true.
This time I need your forgiveness
Just like you need mine.
Tell me how it is
That you dont want what hes giving
It aint no sin, boy,
To be forgiven.(from Strawfoot)
Every audience member wondered if Edwards were talking to them.
After a couple of songs, the guy next to me leaned over to his friend
and said, Are these guys Christians or something?
Its a good and inevitable question, one that the band deals
with constantly. The answer: Edwards is, the others are not. As
a band, they avoid the Christian label like the plague,
but personally, Edwards embraces it. I very much consider
myself a Christian, Edwards told the Denver Post. I
believe in the Bible and God. Everything the Bible says, I believe.
Its just who I am.
16 Horsepower is the rock equivalent of Jonathan Edwards, the brilliant
18th Century fire and brimstone preacher whose sermon Sinners
in the Hands of an Angry God is required reading in most American
Literature courses. I cant prove it, but Im willing
to bet that there is a genetic connection between J. Edwards and
E. Edwards. J. Edwards was notable for his blatant and unflinching
adherence to the scariest parts of the Biblethe stuff about
hell and damnation and eternal judgment. And E. Edwards is notable
for the same thinglooking an audience in the eye and telling
them exactly what he thinks about their prospects for the afterlife.
Its a chilling experience, but one that somehow hasnt
turned audiences off. In a recent article in the Dutch magazine
M, Said el Hadji wrote, [Edwards songs] call
up images of lost souls in hazy, surreal landscapes in which the
war between God and Satan is waged forever. You taste the Christian
feeling of guilt. But 16 Horsepower is beauteous and comforting.
Edwards, thank God, is nothing like those gospel-rock singers whose
music only serves as a shop window for the edifying message, those
pseudo-musicians. Edwards is the only scout of Godas he sees
himself[and] I like to listen willingly.
Its impossible to separate Edwards spirituality from
his music. This is not just because he sings about spiritual things,
but because he has created a spiritual music. In art, there is a
difference between a spiritual message and a spiritual style, and
Edwards embodies that difference. Creed is a band that has spiritual
contentthat is, they sing about vague spiritual things (Can
you take me higher?). Edwards music has spiritual content,
too, but it also achieves a spiritual style that is rare in rock
music. Edwards music is somehow transcendental; it lifts itself
from material things and opens a doorway into the spiritual world.
Recently when asked in an interview how he brings spirituality
into his music, Edwards sang his version of Bob Dylans Nobody
Cept You. His way of responding is telling: Edwards
cant explain it without doing it. He is infused with spirituality,
a longing for God and heaven and a regret that he cant quite
find them on his own. That longing and regret find their way into
every song, inspiring some of the most extraordinary and significant
music on the cultural landscape today. As Edwards told rock critic
Mark Brown in the Rocky Mountain News,"I cant
do anything else. I dont know how to do anything else. Ive
never made any other kind of music that was more simplistic or lighthearted.
Its just not what I do; its not what Ive been
given to do."